A shattered mind in a broken body fighting for survival
Showing posts with label Napoleon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Napoleon. Show all posts

Monday, March 21, 2011

Napoleon: The Little Man Who Couldn't

DISCLAIMER: Please note that the following "history lesson" is meant to be a personal opinion and commentary on historical knowledge. As such, I will not be citing sources. I do understand that historians do a lot of difficult work attempting to sift through the ashes of the past. I would not like to take credit away from these dedicated individuals. For this particular piece, my inspiration, and perhaps some of my more obscure facts, have come from Edith Saunder's The Hundred Days and Jeremy Black's The Battle of Waterloo. If this style of not citing facts in a blog post bothers you, please email me at breadcrumb124@gmail.com and I will be more than happy to provide you with exact citations...or else I'll admit that I'm simply shooting the breeze and was unable to pull the wool over your eyes (that's right. I did just use two cliche idioms in one sentence. I bet you wish you were this awesome.) Also, I will be giving a more in depth approach today, much more so than last Saturday. A large portion of this will be drawn from a paper that I wrote for a class. For readability's sake, I have removed my citations. Again, I do not want anyone to think that these ideas are original to me. If you'd like a list of works cited, email me.


Today, I am going to discuss my reasons that I think Napoleon failed in his bid for world power. 

As dawn broke across the horizon, the incessant rain finally stopped. The men stirred from their sleep and began their morning rituals. They had spent the previous night camped on the rain-soaked fields, and it had been miserable. In addition to the rain, the men had not eaten very much food over the course of the previous day because of their army’s rapid march. They foraged for their food and waited, occasionally glancing nervously across the field. As they watched and waited, the men wondered why they had not yet been attacked by the enemy army on the other side of the field. They had cause to wonder as they did because the general in charge of the opposing army was none other than Napoleon Bonaparte. This great man had marched his armies through almost every nation on the continent of Europe. France had dominated Europe because Napoleon had masterminded the defeats of Austria, Prussia, Spain, and the Russians. It had seemed that this man was truly a god of war. His men revered him; they did not think that it was possible for him to fail them. This godhood had been granted to him by his men because he had given them everything. He had made them a proud people, and one that had become intoxicated on the glory days of an invincible army. Napoleon was greatly feared by his adversaries; they had seen their armies crushed at Jena, Austerlitz, and Borodino, to name just a few. It was not until the majority of the nations of Europe rose up against him that he was finally defeated. Even then, the allied nations, Austria, Prussia, Russia, and Great Britain, chose to avoid direct conflict with the army led personally by Napoleon. This man was a military genius. Thus, the men preparing for battle on the opposite ridge were puzzled about the lethargic behavior that this great man seemed to be showing.
On that day, June 18th 1815, Napoleon Bonaparte would fight once again for the chance to dominate Europe. However, it was not to be. On the fields of Waterloo, the battle was fought that would end Napoleon’s military career forever. This master tactician was not able to overcome the insurmountable odds that day. France’s empire came crashing down with her emperor; Europe was allowed to breathe again after living in a state of war for more than twenty years. The loss at Waterloo came as a shock to the French. Napoleon, the great warrior, had somehow failed to lead his men to victory. Sir Arthur Wellesley, better known as the Duke of Wellington, and Field Marshal Blücher were able to bring Napoleon’s grasping ambition to an end, once and for all. The victors, the British, Prussians, Belgians, Germans, and Dutch, made their fair share of mistakes in the days leading up to the final battle, and came very close to losing the battle. The Anglo-Dutch army under the command of Wellesley was composed of mostly second-rate soldiers from Holland, Belgium, and Germany; even the majority of the British soldiers were lacking in proper training. The Prussian army was not much better off; the large bulk of its soldiers were militiamen who had never seen combat. During the course of the day-long battle, it is said that nearly 10,000 men in Wellesley’s army deserted him. In spite of these problems, Wellesley and Blücher were still able to come away with a victory. The principle reasons behind this were Wellesley’s prior experiences in battle, Napoleon’s illness, and Napoleon’s poor choice of commanders for his army.

Stay tuned next week for the exciting conclusion of this three part series on Napoleon!

~The Piebald Penguin

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Thoughts on Napoleon

DISCLAIMER: Please note that the following "history lesson" is meant to be a personal opinion and commentary on historical knowledge. As such, I will not be citing sources. I do understand that historians do a lot of difficult work attempting to sift through the ashes of the past. I would not like to take credit away from these dedicated individuals. For this particular piece, my inspiration, and perhaps some of my more obscure facts, have come from Edith Saunder's The Hundred Days and Jeremy Black's The Battle of Waterloo. If this style of not citing facts in a blog post bothers you, please email me at breadcrumb124@gmail.com and I will be more than happy to provide you with exact citations...or else I'll admit that I'm simply shooting the breeze and was unable to pull the wool over your eyes (that's right. I did just use two cliche idioms in one sentence. I bet you wish you were this awesome.)

It's a conversation that I'm sure you've had many times. It seems to come up when discussing the grand over-arching history of the world. Or it comes up if you're just plain tired of that accent. Regardless, we, here in America, have a strong distaste for the French. Alright, I'll admit, it's more of a national loathing. Perhaps it's irrational and perhaps not. Inevitably the topic arises that the French love two things: the color pink and running away from a fight. Predictably, the one person in the discussion who has French roots, or just loves French wine, brings up that last ditch effort to save face in light of a history of failures (this is said with a great deal of sarcasm). We all know who saved the French, right? (Hint: it wasn't King John II or Vercingetorix...yeah put that one in your pipe and smoke it...) Obviously the savior of French national pride is none other than Napoleon Bonaparte (it's always been interesting to note that we call him "Napoleon" rather than "Bonaparte". Especially in light of how he refer to men like "Patton", "Hitler", "Wellington"...but I digress). Ok, I said it. We all know that Napoleon made France a great nation; he conquered Europe; he improved the infrastructure of the country (that's a fancy way of saying he had things and stuff built...like roads); Napoleon even worked to codify the laws. Basically, he was a great guy...well, not in stature; everyone knows that he was really short (like 5' 6"). But at least he had a big ego to go with it. At any rate, he saved France from the ignominy of being the most worthless nation on the planet...or did he? Was he really a great conqueror? Was he a military genius?

The truth about Napoleon seems to be that he was an energetic and ambitious man. He made some good decisions, some extremely bad ones, and then a few that were neither good nor bad. It is these latter decisions that concern us. For we know that the good ones were certainly good. Like joining the military in a turbulent time; or reorganizing the army to operate under the corps system; or even in his initial ability to pick subordinates. We also know which decisions were remarkably awful. For example, his decision to invade Russia; or his decision to place family members on the thrones of European nations; or his decision to return from exile when the Coalition leaders were all together in Vienna. But there is one major decision that he made that will be debated by historians for generations to come. That decision, of course, is the one that led to the final battle of his career. Waterloo. We use this term now to refer to someone who has had some success earlier but has now experienced a career ending event (like a nation that tries to hold onto its colonies in Southeast Asia and ends up having its military forces decimated by, supposedly, "primitive" guerrillas. Sorry France, I couldn't resist...). Napoleon's defenders will say that he had no choice in the matter. That he did the best he could with what he had. Or that he would have won the battle if such and such a general had done his job. There's also the defense that his physical ailments finally caught up with him. This event has always interested me because a great general was finally humbled before his adversaries.

If you'd like to know what happened to Napoleon at the infamous Battle of Waterloo, stay tuned. Next week, I will give you my in depth thoughts on what went wrong and why the defenders of French martial history should be ashamed to use Napoleon as their key point. Also, my own defense of the French will be upcoming (I promise I don't hate them.).

~The Piebald Penguin